Nutter Butter Oreo Turkey Cupcakes

Cute Turkey Cupcakes using Oreos and Nutter Butters


Get in the Thanksgiving mood with these adorable Nutter Butter Oreo Turkey Cupcakes!  Using these store-bought cookies and some candy corn make these the cutest and easiest cupcakes this time of year!

Who’s ready for stuffing, mountains of mashed potatoes, and the one time of the year I eat Jello!  Yeah, jello.  My grandmother has this incredible jello recipe with cranberries and walnuts and pineapple… I’m not usually a jello fan but I look forward to this dessert every year.  So where’s the recipe?  Well you can find it deep in the abyss of the blog back from 5 years ago.  But photos of jello just never turn out that well, but maybe this year I’ll need to re-post it.

Adorable Turkey Cupcakes for Thanksgiving

I broke off the bottom of my Nutter Butters because I only wanted the top half to show.  I bought some candy eyes from the store and then cut a candy corn to make the orange beak.  But you can use an orange Starburst or M&M if that’s easier. I used a little Fruit Roll-up for the gobble and melted down some almond bark to use as my “glue.”

How to make turkey faces

The feathers!!! I used double chocolate Oreos and candy corn! You can use regular Oreos but I thought the chocolate versions blended in nicely and looked like part of the turkey’s body.   I just pressed the candy corns into the filling and they stuck! Tah-dah!

Using Oreos to make Turkey Cupcakes

Just pop them both onto your frosted cupcakes and there you go! Let the Thanksgiving festivities begin!

Use Oreos and Nutter Butters to make cute Thanksgiving Cupcakes


I have 2 other Turkey Cupcakes so if you want to make a whole family of them you can!

This is a version with round Nutter Butters and no Oreos! 

Thanksgiving Turkey Cupcakes! So cute and perfect for the kids!

And here’s a fun Reese’s Pieces version!  

Turkey Cupcakes for Thanksgiving

Turkey Cupcakes

Turkey Cupcakes


1 box devil's food cake mix (Pillsbury is my favorite)
3 eggs
1/2 C. oil
1/2 C. buttermilk or milk
1 C. sour cream
1 C. butter, softened
2 tsp. vanilla extract
1/3 C. unsweetened cocoa powder
2 Tbsp. milk
2-3 1/2 C. powdered sugar
24 Nutter Butters
24 Oreos
Candy Corn (about 6 per cupcake)
candy eyes
red candy to make gobbles (Fruit Roll-ups or Starbursts)
frosting or melted almond bark for "glue"


1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees and line pans with cupcake liners.
2. Mix cake mix, eggs, oil, buttermilk and sour cream together until smooth.
3. Fill cupcake liners 3/4 full and bake for 15-20 minutes or until an inserted knife comes out clean.
4. Let cool.
5. Frosting: Beat butter until smooth. Add vanilla extract, cocoa powder, milk and 1 C. powered sugar. Continue to add powdered sugar until you reach your desired consistency.
6. Frost cupcakes.
7. (See photos) Use your melted almond bark to "glue" on your eyes, beaks (cut-up candy corn or orange M&M) and gobbles. I simply dipped a toothpick into the melted chocolate and dabbed it on what I was "glueing." Split your Oreos (you can eat the un-frosted side) and press candy corns into the cream filling to make "feathers." Press your turkey faces and feathers into the frosted cupcakes to make them look like the photos.

5 thoughts on “Nutter Butter Oreo Turkey Cupcakes

  1. 1
    Patty K says:

    These are winners too! Now the question is which turkey version to make?

  2. 2

    These are so adorable and a fantastic edible kid craft, too. Pinning!

  3. 3
    Hannah says:

    Hi Lizzy! I was wondering if you would ever consider doing a “what’s in my kitchen” post? You know, all of your favorite baking tools, and such…

Speak Your Mind


Never miss a recipe! Sign-up for email updates!