The Story:
I am working about 12 hours a day, 6 days a week right now. So do I have much time to bake? Sadly not. But I decided to bake one of my favorite cupcakes and do something a little different with it this time.
This is a new take on my Oreo Cupcakes and with the help of some buttermilk and some crushing abilities, I have found my new favorite Devil’s Food Cake Mix cake recipe. Seriously, the cake is fabulous.
Cakes:
24 teaspoons Oreo crumbs
¼ cup water
½ cup buttermilk
½ cup oil
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 cup sour cream
3 eggs
Devil’s Food Cake Mix
Oreo Buttercream:
8 ounces cream cheese
¼ cup butter
Oreo cream from cookies
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 ½- 3 ½ cups powdered sugar
2 tablespoons heavy cream or milk
1 cup Oreo crumbs, sifted
Directions:
1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees and line 24 muffins tins with cupcake liners
2. Separate about 24 Oreos. Scrape off the cream centers and set aside for later, and put the cookies in the food processor. Or if you are a poor college student, put them in a plastic bag to crunch by hand.
3. Sift the crushed Oreos. You will need 1 cup sifted cookies for the buttercream, so set that aside, and then add the extra sifted cookies to the larger pieces that did not sift.
4. Place 1 teaspoon of larger/extra sifted cookie into the bottom of each cupcake liner.
5. In a large bowl, use a whisk to combine water, buttermilk, oil, sour cream and vanilla extract.
6. One at a time, add the eggs. Be sure to stir well in between each addition, you do not need to beat the eggs though.
7. Slowly add Devil’s food cake mix while stirring.
8. Fill cupcake liners (with the cookie crumbs on the bottom) ¾ full and bake for 13-18 minutes depending on how hot your oven gets. The tops should spring back when you touch them.
9. Place into air tight containers as they cool to seal in moisture.
10.Oreo Buttercream: For 5 minutes, beat cream cheese, butter and the Oreo cream centers you scraped off from the Oreos.
11. Add vanilla, powdered sugar and heavy cream and let beat again.
12. Stir in Oreo crumbs and pipe onto cooled cupcakes.
YUM! Can I come steal one?
I've sometimes put half an Oreo cookie as the base for cupcakes but your idea of crushed cookies as a base is much better. Can't wait to make some. Thanks.
Louise, that is what I originally did in my Oreo cupcakes, I love doing both!
Yum! I love how you actually incorporated the Oreo cream into the icing itself!
Oh my heaven! These sound good. I just recently found your blog. I made the carrot cupcakes with the white chocolate frosting at Easter and they were a big hit.
Oooooh!! these look good , I love your frosting ,it reminds me of the oreos mcflurry ,yummmm!!!
Looks great!
Just found your blog tonight when searching for a nutella recipe. I am SO excited about trying all the wonderful sounding recipes on here, I just read through EVERY one and they look amazing!!
when you make a full batch of these cupcakes, how many packages of oreos did you need?
Just one package is plenty, you will have a few extra to snack on the next day:)
Hi Lizzy absolutely love your site! I notice devils food cake is in a lot of your recipes. What quantity is the cake mix you use? Or do you have a recipe for it? I'm in Australia and can't wait to make these tomorrow!
The boxes are about 18.25 ounces, I hope you can find some mixes that work in Australia!
Hi Lizzy, I love, love, love your site. All your cupcakes look so delicious and your presentation is gorgeous. I tried making this recipe the cake came out so moist and soft but it fell in the middle. Of course I'm going to try it again but do you have any suggestions on what I may have done wrong?
Cupcakes fall for two reasons. First, you over beat your eggs, or second, you open your oven too often to check if they are done. I hope that helps!
Lizzy, this looks like another great recipe! Usually my cupcakes are always falling though too! I was once taught to "rotate" (flip the cupcake pans and turn them 180) half way through baking so that it cooks more evenly… is this opening the oven to check to often though?
Turning the cupcake pans around can help in certain ovens. But unless I have to do it, I don't. When you do it, just try to do it as quickly, but more importantly as gently as you can. Don't bump the pans into the back of the oven or into the other pan, this will cause air to release from the cupcakes and it will make them fall. Try adding an extra 1/4 cup of flour to your batter, that always helps me.
Found you on pinterest & made these tonight for a party – a huge hit! Thank you!
Made these, and they were amazing! Now I am making a HUGE batch of them for a birthday party. Thanks for the recipe:)
Hi there. I literally just finished making these cupcakes for the first time. I'm curious as to how you got your icing to stand up. I followed it to the tee and ended up with a gray soupy mixture. It tastes good but sadly doens't look as amazing as yours do. What's the secret??
Did you melt your butter? If you did, NEVER let your butter melt for buttercream
Also, just add your powdered sugar slowly until it reaches the right consistency. Depending on the brand you use, it make take more than the recipe calls for. Good luck!
Yes, I warmed both the butter and cream cheese for 30 seconds because they were so cold from the fridge and it was past my bed time ;o). And I didn't add the powdered sugar slowly. Just dumped it all in at one (novice baker!). Does beating it for 5 minutes really make it that fluffy? Or do you find it takes longer than that? PS- thanks for all the recipes. Looking forward to making the Andes Mint ones next.
Also, does it make a difference if you use sweetcream butter or margarine in place of the butter? Do you have a whipped cream frosting recipe just in case there are those that aren't a fan of cream cheese? Thanks again!
)
For a buttercream, just use butter. For a whipped cream frosting recipe, you can check out my Pumpkin Pie cupcakes, or just whip the whipped cream, add 1/2 cup of powdered sugar, then add the oreo crumbs. Good luck!
Just beat the butter for a few minute on medium high, You should notice a difference in the texture and color. Also, after you add your powdered sugar, let it beat for 2 minutes.
Awesome! Thank you so much Lizzy! Incredible site. Looking forward to making many more of your recipes
This is an amazing site! So many creative recipes and the cupcakes look beautiful!
I just finish making this goodies, I just love the texture, they are so moist and heavy…love them. This is my second recipe from your site and I am IN LOVE with the results, NEVER have a cupcake as good as these, I will have my winter vacation at work very soon and I can not wait to be baking ALL YOUR RECIPES!!! I mix both of your Oreo receipes to make this one, and it came up really good (oreo cookie at the bottom and crumbs on the icing) the only problem I have it was the icing, it wasn't hard enough (I have the same problem when I make Andes mint cholocate cupcakes), and no, didn't melt the butter and yes, I add one extra cup of confectionary sugar…any other suggestions?? THANKS SO MUCH FOR SHEARING!!! ….Fatima
Forgot to ask you Lizzy, what camera do you use to shot your pictures?? love the detail and how clear the zooming image comes out..great photography!!…Fatima
Fatima, I will be doing a buttercream tutorial soon, so hopefully that will help you out. What I usually do, is just keep adding powdered sugar until the consistency is right. As for my camera. Up until about 5 posts ago, I used a Canon Powershot that is 10 years old. Now I use a beautiful T3i, but I have no idea how to use it.
Lizzy….you ROCK!!!!! thanks A LOT for all your tips and comments, I am baking a crazy combination between your receipes and some ideas on on my own. Walnut cranberry muffins! I will let you know how it went. BTW it looks like your recepes are for a great size 24 cupcakes all the time. Thanks for the tips about the camera, mine sucks when it comes to food photography, I will check that Cannon Powershot for sure!!! beatiful work Lizzy….Fatima
Just finished making a batch of these and they are outstanding! What a fantastic recipe. Thanks for sharing
I just made these cupcakes last weekend. everyone LOVED them You’re recipes are wonderful! I can’t wait to make some of the other ones! Keep posting!!!!!!!
Hey just wondering do you have to add sour cream cause I dont like sour cream! Is there a replacement?:) thanks!
The sour cream makes the cake a little more dense and moist. You can add 1/2 cup of plain or vanilla yogurt or just not add anything.
Alright thank you! Btw your cupcakes look amazing!!:)
Hi Lizzy just wondering if you have some suggestions for those of us who live at high altitude? Baking is a challenge!
I do most of my baking at high altitude. Send me an email and I will let you know some tips!